Flipping and Capital Gains

A common dilemma for real estate investors is the issue of flipping and taxes. In this article, we look specifically at the tax issues associated with flipping and capital gains.

In recent years, people have been looking at the real estate market as they once looked at the stock market, eyes filled with dollar signs. Flipping became a popular real estate investment strategy to make fast cash. However, one thing that people forgot in their haste to play the game was to be properly prepared with the knowledge to avoid paying high taxes on their profits. Towards that end, here's some noteworthy information about taxes as you think about your flipping strategy.

First, in order to avoid overly onerous "ordinary income taxes" on flipping properties you must have the property treated as a capital gain. Most often, if you sell the property in less than a year, you will be taxed at the ordinary income tax rate, which can be in excess of 35 %. Only when you've held the property for more than a year, does the long-term capital gains tax of 15 % (for most tax payers) come into play. In order to have the property treated as a capital gain you must show that you had no intention of flipping that property. Ironically, this could entail holding the property for this extended period of time which counteracts the whole point of flipping - which is to make money fast.

Also, it's not only about "when" you flip, but about "how often" you flip. If you flip too often, the IRS may view that this strategy is your "trade or business" and therefore the profits you make are subject to ordinary income and self-employment taxes. And you don't want that.

Secondly, if you want to employ other strategies to avoid big taxes like installment or structured sales or private annuity treatment while flipping, you can't. Spreading tax out doesn't work because the property is not labeled investment property. This again goes back to issue of holding periods and intention of sale.

If you are hoping to use the 1031 exchange strategy as the approach for flipping and capital gains, again you will find yourself between a rock and a hard place. 1031 exchanges are reserved for investment properties only and if you can prove, through holding periods and intention, that the property is a capital gain or investment property, you will not be eligible. The IRS supports investors and savers, not speculators and gamblers.

Once most of your tax deferral options are exhausted, your last resort for flipping and capital gains may be to have that property re-characterized to a capital gain property by moving in to it and treating it as your personal residence. It may work, but holding even longer holding periods apply.

In conclusion, flipping can be an exciting and fast way to make money. But when it comes to taxes it is hard to make flipping and capital gains work together.

Capital Gains and Flipping Properties

Flipping and taxes are a frequent issue for property investors, since for a long while people have been looking at the real estate market in the exact same way they look at the stock market. The instance of flipping in the real estate market became a great way to get quick funds.

But one of the things that people usually don't check on is the way to avoid the high tax bills on their profits. One of the first ways to avoid high taxes on your profit is treating the particular investment as a capital gain. The usual thing that occurs is that the if you sell a certain property in less than one year you will end up paying less tax, as this amount will be the same as the ordinary income tax rates which is in the 35% bracket. If you have owned the property for more than a year then you will have to pay the long term capital gains tax of 15%.

The way that you will get this property treated as a capital gain is if you can show that you had not tried to flip it. But in order to do this you would have to hold the property for a period of time which would go against the whole notion of flipping the property to make a quick earning. And another key fact of the matter is how often you flip, because if you flip properties too often the IRS will check your records and see if you are doing this for a living and then tax you in all the necessary area's.

Investing in Real Estate, Flipping Houses, and Income Taxes

Understand the tax consequences of flipping houses, rehabbing houses, and how to defer taxes with the 1031 Exchange before you get into real estate investing. Problems arise when real estate investors don't follow federal and state tax laws. This is why you need professional advice. Although I am not a tax advisor, here are some common mistakes beginning real estate investors make by not understanding tax liabilities:

Flipping Houses

The reason flipping houses is a mistake for some beginners is that they don't know the income tax consequences. One problem with flipping houses, or selling too many properties too quickly, the IRS could say that your real estate business is your trade, subject to ordinary income and self-employment taxes.

Self-employment tax, a social security and Medicare tax primarily for individuals who work for themselves, is similar to the social security and Medicare taxes withheld from the paycheck of most employees. The self-employment tax rate costs you 15.3% of your profits. (However, this may provide retirement benefits.)

Rehabbing Houses

Another common mistake that beginning investors make is selling a property after holding it for almost a year. Some rehabbers work part time on a fixer and take six months to get the house ready. Add on two months to sell with a 60 day closing, and they're up to ten months. To take advantage of the low 15% capital-gains tax rate, you must keep the investment property for at least a year before selling. If you sell before a year, your tax rate, the usual capital gains rate of 35%, could eat up a significant amount of your profits.

If you're rehabbing houses, be patient. You could save thousands in taxes by holding your property just a few more weeks.

1031 Exchange

However, the Internal Revenue Code provides real estate investors away to defer capital gains taxes indefinitely. Section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code provides a tax-free exchange. Also known as a "like-kind" exchange, this code allows you to sell a business or investment property and defer capital-gains taxes by immediately reinvesting the gains into a similar piece of property. The key, replacing a business or investment with similar property, means that no gain gets paid to the investor. Any profit taken out of escrow gets taxed. This means that beginning investors might take out a portion of the profit after they carefully explore their tax liabilities. In other words, talk to an accountant and find out what your tax would be according to your current usual income. Many business owners take advantage of this because they have many business deductions.

The big mistake beginning real estate investors make doing a 1031 tax-free exchange, taking possession of the profits, voids the tax deferment. You must declare the sale of your property to be a part of a 1031 exchange before you sell the property. Then you have the money placed in a trust account held by an intermediary until you purchase the new investment property. You have 45 days to identify a replacement property and 180 days to close on the new investment. You can't purchase a primary residence or a vacation home with funds from an investment property and defer taxes in a 1031 exchange.

The best advice for beginning real estate investors:
Talk to an accountant.

Would you be better off making extra money, even if you must pay taxes?

© 2005 Jeanette J. Fisher.